Skip to main content
You have permission to edit this article.
Book review: ‘Who Is Maud Dixon?’ a clever debut novel about a debut novel

Book review: ‘Who Is Maud Dixon?’ a clever debut novel about a debut novel

  • 0

"Who is Maud Dixon?" by Alexandra Andews. (Little, Brown and Company/TNS)

"Who Is Maud Dixon?" by Alexandra Andrews; Little, Brown (336 pages, $28)


The title of this smart, slyly clever debut from journalist Alexandra Andrews says it all. Just who is this Maud Dixon whose first novel is the most talked about book in the history of publishing?

Discussions about the book are rivaled by the secret identity of Maud. All that is known about the author is that Maud Dixon is a pseudonym — she doesn’t do book signings or appearances on the “Today” show or have a social media presence or attend writers’ conferences.

An even better question in “Who Is Maud Dixon?” is who is Florence Darrow, a lowly editorial assistant at a New York City publishing firm. Florence was always told by her hard-working single mother that she was bound for greatness. That’s not likely to happen at this point, no matter how much she has distanced herself from her upbringing.

Florence was used to being the smartest person in the room in her small Florida hometown, but that was before she moved to New York. Now she can’t quite fit in with those coworkers raised on the Upper East Side. Her clothes are wrong, she doesn’t know how to pronounce words and she will blurt out inappropriate comments. She wants to be a novelist — “to mold entire worlds according to her vision”— but she hasn’t written a word in ages.

Through a fluke of circumstances, Florence is asked to be a live-in assistant to Maud, whose real name is Helen Wilcox. The house is remote and, at first, Helen seems willing to mentor Florence on her writing.

Andrews skillfully delves into each woman’s true personality, driving “Who Is Maud Dixon?” into an incisive look at ambition, greed, identity and celebrity worship. Florence is a cypher, soaking up as much as she can in reinventing herself, having built “dark rooms within herself.” She also has more than a little larceny in her heart — not above stalking her married lover’s family or sending his wife photos and text messages.

Helen is mercurial, cruel, dismissive of others, and this second book she is writing might rival Jack Torrance’s gibberish in “The Shining.” A research trip to Morocco changes the dynamic when Florence wakes up in a hospital following a horrific car accident. No Helen, but all her identification is in Florence’s purse; making it an opportune time for Florence to trade up identities.

Andrews’ wicked sense of humor and intelligent plotting deliver a briskly paced novel filled with inventive twists reminiscent of “All About Eve,” “Gaslight” and any Patricia Highsmith novel. “Who Is Maud Dixon?” establishes Andrews as an author to watch.

Stay up-to-date on what's happening

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Most Popular

Jefferson-Madison Regional Library has several events scheduled for the week ahead. Go to for registration details.

PIHLADELPHIA — Before Michelle Zauner wrote "Crying in H Mart," her heartbreakingly beautiful memoir about grief, food, and her Korean American identity, she had already created two works of art about losing her mother, Chongmi, to cancer in 2014: the Japanese Breakfast albums "Psychopomp" and "Soft Sounds from Another Planet." "Psychopomp" opens with "In Heaven," with a verse about the family ...

Manuel and Geiszel Godoy are military veterans, and they believe deeply in social justice. But above all, they are entrepreneurs who saw an underdeveloped sector in their industry and dove in. "We have to show that we can pull a Tyler Perry as a community," Manuel Godoy, president of Black Sands Entertainment, says in a recent video interview. "The idea is that the bigger the company gets, the ...

Over a year into the pandemic, your bookshelves may be so crowded with books that you can’t imagine adding another. But a 3-year-old dog named Stella will have you rethinking that. Not familiar with the brown pup with a white belly, a mix of Catahoula and Australian cattle dog? She’s quite the social media sensation, with 788,000 followers on Instagram, 101,000 followers on YouTube and 28,000 ...

Here are the bestsellers for the week that ended Saturday, April 24, compiled from data from independent and chain bookstores, book wholesalers and independent distributors nationwide, powered by NPD BookScan © 2021 NPD Group. (Reprinted from Publishers Weekly, published by PWxyz LLC. © 2021, PWxyz LLC.) HARDCOVER FICTION 1. "A Gambling Man" by David Baldacci (Grand Central) Last week: — 2. ...

"The Newcomer" by Mary Kay Andrews; St. Martin’s Press (448 pages, $28.99) ——— On the rare occasions that I’m driving on the Pinellas barrier islands and spot an OG beach motel — those low-slung, cozy, pastel-painted relics tucked in among the towering condos and raucous bars — I feel a little warm tug of nostalgia for the funky, friendly places I remember. Mary Kay Andrews’ imagination works ...

“The 1619 Project: A New Origin Story” expands upon the New York Times Magazine publication from 2019 that centers the country's history around slavery and led to a Pulitzer for commentary for the project's creator, Nikole Hannah-Jones. “Born on the Water” is a volume for young people, based on a student's family tree assignment, with words by Hannah-Jones and Renee Watson and illustrations by Nikkolas Smith.

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.



Breaking News

Breaking Sports News

News Alert